5 Stars - A Lucky Find and an Instant Favorite! Stumbled across this place completely by chance--and wow, what a find! We knew we were onto something special, from the smell of fresh dough and the garlicky crust was that perfect balance of crispy and chewy. You definitely can tell they actually care about what they're serving here. The staff was warm and welcoming, like you were walking into a friend's place for dinner. No frills, no gimmicks--just seriously good pizza made by people who clearly know what they're doing. Can't believe we found this spot by accident, but we're already planning our next visit. What a gem!

"The best NYC-style pizza we've had in Florida! The marinara sauce is hands down the best--perfect for both pizza and pasta. The owner, Mike, is incredibly thoughtful and passionate about his business, which truly shows in the quality of the food and service. Highly recommend

never leave reviews but this place was top tier. service was amazing. you can tell they care. pizza was amazing. someone get dave portney out here. no reason they shouldn't have a line out the door everyday.

Always great pizza and fun atmosphere when crowded and busy. Solid service and pricing is great. It's a good pizzeria.

pizza is good. 7.1 - 7.4 depending on what day you come. The gelato is outstanding. The staff are very nice.

Heard about the place so I wanted to give it a try. Nice atmosphere. We started off with the minestrone soup, which had a great flavor. Then we ordered mussels marinara, which had a nice little kick of spice. Garlic rolls were awesome to dip in the sauce as well. We ordered the homemade manicotti and chicken Parm and both were very delicious with great flavor. Our waiter Steve was awesome. Great personality and very friendly and gave us great suggestions. We ended the meal with homemade cheesecake which was really creamy and delicious as well. They have a wide variety of desserts and gelato too. Will definitely go back. If you want great quality, Italian food, come to Bella Amici!

We read so many good reviews on Yelp we decided to try this local pizzeria. Parking was in the lot so it was easy. We were greeted immediately and could sit anywhere. There was Italian music playing and a pizza maker behind the counter. Our server was quick to bring our drinks and take our order. It was a full menu along with an impressive and interesting variety of pizza selections, pastas, Italian entrees, hot sandwiches etc. We got the supreme pizza but substituted red for green peppers. It was quiet when we arrived early evening but the restaurant got busier as the night went on. Our pizza came out in good time and we really enjoyed it. I also ordered spumoni gelato and it was very good. They had a lot of good gelato choices as well as many other homemade cakes and desserts. We thought the prices were fair. They have a special on Thursday night - All you can Eat pizza or pasta $20. That seemed worth trying if you are very hungry!! LOL.

How have I never been to this place yet?!?!?! Came across this hidden gem after seeing the 5-star rating. The pizza is so good and the salad, wings and chicken Parm were all top notch. 5/5 rating well deserved!

6 Stars, both for food and service. Amazing, visited in May from RI, everything on the menu was fantastic. Pizza is my favorite food and Bella Amici is as good as any top pizza shops in the northeast. Had the pizza with Chicago Sausage which exceeded expectations. Salad was excellent paired with awesome store made dressing. Gelato, all flavors were great. Cannolis- as good as any bakeries in Boston or Providence Store made garlic knots delicious Desserts, especially the strawberry cheesecake all looked great. Can't wait to comeback. Pasta dishes served to neighboring tables give more reasons for multiple visits on our next trip. Michael and John were great hosts. Wish I took more pictures to share with fellow yelpers.